Partner of thinking, and lack. Training as a psychoanalyst.
Loading color scheme
Partner of thinking, and lack. Training as a psychoanalyst.
The ‘Christ of the tribute’ by Tiziano Vecellio.

The painting in the background is ‘Christ of the tribute, or of the coin’ (1568) by Tiziano Vecellio (now at Dresden, ‘Gemaeldegalerie’)/ Original painting by Stefano Frassetto[1].
“My dear love, Sigmund Freud, ‘Letters to his fiancée’ (1883).
(…) Another painting enchanted me, ‘Christ of the tribute’ by Tiziano, that I already knew but without particularly noticing it. The head of Christ, my dear, is the only likely one that we can believe had such a man. Even I felt like I had to believe that he had been so important indeed, because the representation is so successful. And in all of that, nothing divine, a noble human face very far from beauty, and severity, innerity, depth, a superior gentleness, a deep passion; if you cannot find all this in that painting, then physiognomy doesn’t exist. I would have gladly taken it away, but there were too many people : young English women copying, or sitting and speaking softly, or walking and watching. Therefore I walked away moved…”
Sigmund Freud, ‘Letters to his fiancée’ - December 20, 1883
edited by Marina Bilotta Membretti / Cernusco sul Naviglio - June 14, 2020 Sunday
TutorSalus.net - Freudian journalism
[1] Stefano Frassetto is born in Turin in 1968. After his degree in Architecture at ‘Politecnico’ he begun as graphic novelist for local magazines. In the ‘90s he edited in France, on ‘Le Réverbère’ and on ‘Libération’ : then he created ‘Ippo’ for ‘Il Giornalino’ and then the stripe ‘35MQ’ for the swiss magazine ‘20 Minuti’. In 2000 he came into ‘La Stampa’ newspaper as portraitist for cultural page and the insert ‘Tuttolibri’, then for the weekly ‘Origami’. Today he works also for the swiss magazine ‘Le Temps’. In 2022 Frassetto published his first comic review ‘35MQ : 2012/2022 Dieci anni di inettitudine’.
A three-person job.

Screenshot from the trailer of the film 'The Hurt Locker' by Kathryn Bigelow (U.S.A. 2008): the young boy Beckham manages to save a penalty kick, winning the bet with American Sergeant Jones.
I start again from Petra[1], an ancient city never forgotten, even if today tourists visit it on organized 'tours' that tell even what would not cross one's mind to ask.
During a work break while filming ‘The Hurt Locker’[2], actor Guy Pearce—Sergeant Matt Thompson, and the first E.O.D. bomb technician to enter the scene—also went to Petra with other members of the crew. He admits with surprise: "Here, people watch you, they don't miss anything you do... Back home in the West, there is indifference[3]”.
The work of an E.O.D. [4] technician is appreciated among the military, but also deeply by those who actually live down there and find bombs literally between their legs when stepping out into the street, buried just beneath old, eaten-away asphalt and stone pebbles. Yet, at the same time, it is a conflicted job, fought rationally and with Conscience by those who truly want those bombs to explode, no matter who gets hurt!
"War is a drug" is the unsettling premise of the film, and an E.O.D. technician is not a hero, in fact. "I wanted to describe the chaos of war...", says Kathryn Bigelow, an intelligent and capable director according to the film's actors, and also the first woman ever to win the Oscar for Best Director in 2010.
"And I wanted to reconstruct 'that' walk, of a lonely man going to defuse the bomb in the middle of the city. I wanted the viewer to take that walk with 'him'... If I succeeded, that was my goal."
"I could only get a fraction of an idea of what an E.O.D. is," confesses Jeremy Renner, who plays E.O.D. bomb technician Sergeant William James in the film. "I wrote pages and pages," he says, "to get inside, to understand...
What is cinema for if not to provoke your thinking or, better yet, multiple conflicting thinking which you didn't have before entering the theater? Or you just pay 11 dollars to be entertained, and you walk out the same as before..."
The film leads us through a surreal and deliberately realistic chronicle-story, but one that is never easy or sadistic. Beckham is the boy from whom Sergeant James buys video games at the market to distract himself after a mission.
"...My name is Beckham" [5], he replies with the boldness of someone who, at just twelve years old, already knows that you must never, 'never', give your identity to the 'enemy'. He accepts James's bet and wins the five dollars promised for saving that penalty kick. And Beckham himself is 'the hurt locker', 'the keeper of what hurts', which for the American military is also the box where objects to be returned to the family are kept when a soldier dies.
Beckham, the child in the hands of 'his' shrewd adults, is indeed near death when James and his squad find him on a makeshift operating table in an abandoned warehouse. Someone among 'his' people clumsily inserted the explosive device into his small chest, and he is dying, bleeding out and useless to the Cause, because even 'that' bomb will be defused by the 'enemy' technician.
But James, after 'this' mission, cannot manage to leave. Alone on the street, he imagines bringing the child back to his family—who isn't there—or at least finding those who wanted to transform him into a body-bomb, as he calls it. Instead, he calls his wife, who answers from the United States holding their few-months-old baby... He cannot utter a word, but it is his wife's voice, it is 'his' home, it is something.
The filthy merchant leaves him in front of a middle-class house, furnished in a Western style. James enters like a thief and finds himself in front of the master of the house: elegant, a professor with an incomprehensible name, who says he knows many languages and invites the American sergeant to make himself comfortable—he is a guest, right? But 'about Beckham, no, he knows nothing...' In his locker under the bunk, along with fragments of the defused devices—eight hundred and seventy-six he had counted—the American sergeant also keeps his wedding ring.
"She is faithful..." he confesses to his comrades who ask him. And she is also the only one to whom, having returned home to the United States after the deployment that does not force him to go back down there, he can say: "They are short on bomb technicians...".
And she, once again, understands. If war is a drug, as the official commentaries on the film state, two languages and messages are offered to the viewer here.
One of them, however—and a truly grave one—can continue to remain encrypted, repressed, or deliberately misunderstood by those who won't even applaud because the story is not sensational, not catastrophic, not exciting enough...
And that message is that war is consoling—the true consoling 'drug' for those who do not take a single step to build peace in their own lives, and to whom a city and the people living in it do not matter, except as objects to keep or to discard.
Hands can think, as a matter of fact: no human, not even an expert bomb technician, can ever be a robot.
Marina Bilotta Membretti/ Cernusco sul Naviglio – June 7, 2020
TutorSalus.net – Freudian journalism
[1] Petra, ‘The Variegated’—as it was called in ancient times due to the vivid colours of the rock layers—is still located in Jordan, south of Amman. At the center of a vast desert area where the only water comes from rainfall, it possessed an exceptional water network of cisterns and channels carved into the subsoil, which the Romans used as a tool of pressure to eventually subjugate it. It was abandoned in the 8th century and ‘rediscovered’ only in the 19th century. The city of Petra is mentioned in the ‘Qumran Scrolls’, among the oldest surviving copies of biblical books (40% of the identified documents) dating back to the period 150 b.C. - 70 a.D. These documents were found in the West Bank only between 1947 and 1956, and they bear witness to Late Judaism, meaning the Jewish Civilization following the destruction of the Second Temple, which was itself the reconstruction of King Solomon's temple.
[2] Presented in Venice at a preview screening in 2008 during the ‘Venice International Film Festival, ‘The hurt locker’ won six Academy Awards in 2010 for Best Picture, Best Director (Kathryn Bigelow), Best Film Editing, Best Sound Mixing, Best Sound Editing, and Best Original Screenplay (Mark Boal, journalist).[3] The dialogue fragments reported here are taken from the 'backstage' of the film.
[4] E.O.D. stands for ‘end of discussion’ (meaning ‘case closed’ or ‘I don't want to hear another word’) or ‘end of day’, indicating something that must be finished by the end of the workday. However, in the Army, it refers to a volunteer technician expert in Explosive Ordnance Disposal. In the movie, the ‘Bravo Company’ squad consists of three soldiers: two support shooters and one E.O.D. bomb disposal expert who goes out alone to defuse the bomb, or bombs.
[5] David Beckam (London, 1978), awarded as the 2nd best footballer in the world in the 1999 FIFA rankings he is still an icon for many very young fans.
The initial letter of 'perimeter'.

When describing the construction of the huge temple of Solomon[1] king, around 950 b.C., the Bible returns it with a barely accurate value of three : but is certain that it was known already 5.000 years ago, as the ancient Egyptians were able, thanks to it, to draw and to measure the course of the Nile river, whose regular and devastating floods were twisting the geography of the local sites.
However it wasn’t yet named until 1706 when the mathematician William Jones, establishing his value equal to 3,14159 periodic, called it π – maybe the initial letter of ‘perimeter’ which in Greek language sounds περιμετρος – and Euler[2] adopted the symbol in 1737, so rapidly spreading it as a standard.
Since the beginning described as a numerical ratio, constant and mysterious, between the circumference and its diameter, for dozens of centuries π was singled out as 22/7. You can even say that the most ancient definition of π – able as it was said ‘to link the earth to the sky’ – marked the beginning of the Geometry too, a science not requiring a priori theories but effectively conjugating the abstract figures with the livable reality. The critical issue of the borders – always forebonding of risky enmities – at last did find a solution with the science of Geometry, thanks to the areas and solids measurement which well represented Countries and properties to be defended. If a flood of Nile, when receding had changed the geographic feature, the technical measurements before the event returned the reality and a social peace : but that ratio, so constant and ‘unfinished’ and also connecting every bend, halph-spheric then, of the river with its diameter was amazing any incredulous technician in the ancient Egypt.
More over, they started when reporting to their seniors, and the seniors whispering to the highest officials, and up to the divine Pharaoh, why in that mysterious ratio any string of numbers could be included, any formula and even complex simulation were included, without no explanation at all…
Reality was incredibly of a divine lowered among humans and hidden, although present - who know how long and what other forms - incomprehensible but representable, therefore a mistery and a treasure that the society of the Pharaohs was able to to well sip in the centuries, so granting submission and governing too.
In 1906 as a matter of facts, the discovery of a written page was finally enlightening about the goals achieved using the rule of the lever to calculate areas, volumes and centres of gravity : it was the ‘Letter about the method’[3] which Archimedes[4] of Syracuse, a rare scientist and devoted to the monarch and tyrant Gerone II[5] who couldn’t do without him, wrote to Eratosthenes[6] of Alexandria in Egypt, director of the richest Library, right where Archimedes had studied thank to the subsidy of Gerone.
Studying in Egypt, Archimedes[7] could get to analytical tests, datas and very ancient and precious documents which opened the way to a new method, the one to demonstrate a theory by mechanical entities : covering a spiral, for example, let measuring its perimeter, nearest to a circumference which so linked with any curved line and even to the straight, which is a special case of the curved one. And the point itself, then ? Try to measure it without at least you can imagine to zoom it.
We still wonder that Archimedes couldn’t take advantage of algebraic or trigonometric information, because he derived each of his own results by only geometrical media, then surfaces and solids which allowed him to get to concluding theses, and so finally establishing the ‘infinitesimal calculus’ and the ‘limit’ : the circumference was certainly formed by an infinity of equidistant points from a single centre, but it could be assimilated to an ever increasing number of polygons with equal sides, i.e. very regular and in increasing number, and themselves stackable to the circumference, so prooving measurable and no more mysterious indeed.
A proved scientific nature of the motion became preferable to the incomprehensible and unrelated immobility of an abstract, and divine, a priori.
We can say that π has been able to split its audience between aggressive theorists, who always point out issues still open, and on the other hand users, simply thankful for the service offered by this humble value.
Will this be how we govern ?
Marina Bilotta Membretti / Cernusco sul Naviglio - May 31, 2020 Sunday
TutorSalus.net - Freudian journalism
[1] J.J.O’Connor / Honorary Senior Lecturer in ‘Computational Algebra’ e E.F.Robertson / Professor Emeritus of Mathematics at ‘School of Mathematics and Statistics’ - University of St. Andrews (Scotland) are the authors of ‘A history of Pi’ / Agosto 2001 : they cite a verse from the Bible which is both in ‘Book I King 7, 23’ and in ‘Book II Chronicles 4, 2’.
[2] Leonhard Euler (1707 Basilea, Swissland – 1783 Saint Petersburg, Russia), mathematician and physicist, often known as Euler.
[3] The page was at first titled ‘The method of Archimedes of the mechanical theorems, to Eratosthenes’ by the researcher Heiberg who found it at Istanbul, mixed to other papers : the paper is also the Premise to the Treatise of Archimedes ‘On spirals’.
[4] Archimedes ( 287 b.C. – 212 b.C.) was born and dead at Syracuse, in Sicily but he stayed for a long time in Alexandria of Egypt to finish and perfect his studies.
[5] He too from Syracuse (308 b.C. – 215 b.C.), Gerone seized power with the support of the popular classes, but he didn’t twist any law or preceeding institution : so that any ‘tyrant’, in a city-state like Syracuse established by former Greek colonists, was accepted in the Greece of VII and VI century b.C. and by the authorities of Athens too.
[6] Eratosthenes of Cyrene (Cyrene, 276 b.C. – Alexandria of Egypt, 194 b.C.) was a mathematician and a famous geographer : he was appointed as Librarian of the Library in Alexandria of Egypt, the most important Library of the ancient time.
[7] I’d like to cite the interesting Exhibition 2019-2020 ‘Archimedes at Syracuse’ with the machinery of Archimedes but wooden reconstructed to be ‘touched’ and very ‘clapped’ indeed, at the ‘Galleria Civica Montevergini’ in Syracuse-Ortigia, attended by Giovanni Di Pasquale and with the scientific advice of G. Voza e C. P. Voza.
From ‘souff(e)rance’ a ‘douleur’ ??

In an excellent ‘Séminaire’[1] by Jacques Lacan, the famous Parisian psychoanalyst and passionate follower of Freud pointed out a clever game of the unconscious. He showed how the absence or presence of a single letter in a word can bring together or keep apart two meanings that do not exactly resemble each other. The word in question was ‘souffrance’, which the French language translates as 'transit' or 'storage', commonly used in postal services and correspondence.
However, the simple inserting an 'e', changes everything: et voilà! That word becomes soufferance, a suspended tension waiting for a solution, which effectively describes what Freud meant by 'urge'.
Therefore, soufferance would not have a pre-judged destiny toward la douleur (i.e. ‘pain’). if it maintains the quality of ‘souffrance’ - that is, of a 'temporary' storage, a 'transit' in the processing of a satisfactory solution. This solution cannot logically be melancholic or narcissistic as well, even though it often results in being socially compassionate, causing an 'emerging damage'[2].
I find myself, then, sincerely thanking Marjane Satrapi for her remarkable ‘Persepolis’[3], a ‘first’ work written in the first person for the 'first' Iranian graphic novel. The simple drawings are deeply expressive and beautifully set, while the prose is effective and, above all, uncompromising.
The surprising cover already reveals something of a powerful message. In the foreground is the profile of a young woman with closed eyes and a large mole on the side of her nose. In the background, a little girl looks at the reader with wide-open eyes, lacking that mole which Marjane explains appeared precisely during her transformation from an adolescent into a woman, alongside a significant growth in height.
Marjane Satrapi says very little about the choice of the title, ‘Persepolis’, dedicating a rather obscure chapter and just a few scattered hints throughout the narrative to it. Translated from ancient Greek, Persepolis simply means 'city of Persia.' However, it was the second of the five ancient capitals following Pasargadae (and alongside Babylon, Susa, and Ecbatana). It was founded around 515 b.C., 1700 meters above the level of the sea, and about fifty kilometers north of the modern city of Shiraz in the Fars province of Iran.
The history of Persepolis, which Darius turned into the splendid capital of Persia with palaces and terraces, is linked to the mythical 'Jamshid the Radiant.' In the ancient Avestan language, Jam-Shid results from the union of two names and is today a widespread male name. He gives the name 'Throne of Jamshid' to the site where the magnificent remains of Persepolis still stand. Zoroastrian writings state that he was the ruler of an ancient dynasty who received a ring to seal and an inlaid dagger, both of gold, from the 'Omniscient Creator' to bring His law to Earth. One could say that in this mythology, the alliance—even a marital one—with the human, patiently sought by the 'Omniscient Creator,' exists exclusively thanks to an intelligent capacity for 'work' that characterizes men and women on Earth.
"In Greek mythology, heroes are predestined, whereas in 'our' myth, the concept of 'fate' does not exist...", explains the Iranian scholar interviewed by Marjane[4] in the book when she was working with her husband Reza on a project commissioned by the University of Tehran.
As the pages of ‘Persepolis’ turn, the choice of that title finds validation in Marjane’s vicissitudes. She begins with a protected childhood where, as the daughter of progressive, wealthy parents of noble origin, she discovers the dark spots of an ancient, complex, and self-referential culture. Is it normal, ten-year-old Marjane wonders, to blame children for the sins of their fathers? Is it normal to be served at home by a peer because she was sold by 'poor' parents as a family maid? Is it normal to accept that belonging to a social class is socially discriminatory? Marjane considers herself "...born with religion" and as a child often finds herself talking directly to God, "...sure of being the last of the prophets." [5] The resemblance to 'The Radiant' is truly striking.
Then come the years of the Khomeinist dictatorship with its fierce repressions and limitations. If her parents opposed the Shah[6], they cannot support a fundamentalist culture that forbids any initiative and individuality, leading them to decide what other families were already doing: sending their children abroad. In 1984, Marjane leaves for Vienna, where she stays for four years, completing the studies that would have been forbidden to her in Iran, but meeting peers, families, and institutions for which she is unprepared, despite being intelligent and cultured. "I pretended to join in, but I didn't inhale the smoke...", "...then I simulated wild laughter, I was quite credible", "I even went so far as to deny my nationality." [7]
Returning to Iran, she finds the country's repressive atmosphere even more suffocating. Yet, with great determination, she decides: "From today on, I want to change my life..." She meets Reza, with whom she prepares for and passes the 'National Exam' required for the admission to University. One day in the city, to avoid one of the frequent checkpoints of the 'Guardians of the Revolution,' Marjane falsely accuses an innocent bystander of harassment, leading to his arrest. However, she admits that due to the regime, 'public conduct' and 'private conduct' were poles apart. [8]
She then decides to marry Reza, but recalls that by the time she found herself in their marital apartment, she already 'regretted' it.[9] Perhaps for this reason—and despite his lucidity in admitting the 'social pressures' capable of cracking a relationship[10]—she decides to divorce three years later and move to France. There, at twenty-six, she begins her promising career as a cartoonist, precisely thanks to the success of ‘Persepolis’—an engaging, limpid narrative without conclusions about a resistance to the 'new,' in front of which cultural archetypes remain a wall for those who use them.
Marjane admits in the final pages[11] that "When problems are no longer acceptable, the only way to bear the unbearable is to laugh at it..."
But 'work' is either conclusive, or it is nothing. Laughing at it—meaning trivializing it—sounds like a jarring contradiction to that splendid, yet marble ‘Persepolis’, historically founded to seal the divine question to humanity throughout the centuries.
Marina Bilotta Membretti/ Cernusco sul Naviglio – May 1, 2020
TutorSalus.net – Freudian journalism
[1] “Il seminario su ‘La lettera rubata’” in “Jacques Lacan. Scritti” Vol. I edited by Giacomo B.Contri, ‘Giulio Einaudi editore SpA’ 2002 / pagg.27-30
[2] ‘Emerging damage’ together with ‘ceasing profit’ and ‘not emerging profit’, is one of the three configurations of the psychopathological diseconomy in “Un uomo che ha domani”, by Giacomo B. Contri / pag.19, see ‘Opera omnia’ 2015 – ‘Sez. Saggi, testi pro-manuscripto’.
[3] ‘Persepolis’, by Marjane Satrapi/ ‘Rizzoli Lizard’ – Mondadori Libri SpA / 12° edition 2019 (original title ‘Persepolis. Histoire d’une femme insoumise’) was given to me by Laura Santalucia, Federica Membretti, Marco Membretti whom I especially thank for the work they have invited me to do with this substantial autobiography.
[4] ‘Persepolis’, cited p. 337
[5] ‘Persepolis’, cited p. 8
[6] Mohammad Reza Pahlevi was the last Shah of Persia until the Islamic Revolution of 1979 : he abandoned his Country and fled to Egypt where he found asylum.
[7] ‘Persepolis’, cited, p.198-201
[8] ‘Persepolis’, cited, pp.294-295, p.314
[9] ‘Persepolis’, cited, p.326
[10] ‘Persepolis’, cited, p. 347
[11] ‘Persepolis’, cited, p. 275