Partner of thinking, and lack. Training as a psychoanalyst.
Loading color scheme
Partner of thinking, and lack. Training as a psychoanalyst.
From “Mappamondo”, by Massimo Bucchi[2].
In the picture, my working copy in the Studio.
Dreaming is an alibi ?
In “Mappamondo” by Massimo Bucchi I’ve found that yes, dreaming is one’s own, very personal ‘map of the world’. Which however we better not remove when, awake, each of us tries to save oneself as best as one can from global pedagogism.
The comforting alibi of our dreams is surely a defense, but naive and then pregnable, except for a job that is not common at all, whose precious efficacy remains individual, that is not transferable to third parties.
‘West awoke late in the East day’ is a very nice aphorism coined by Massimo Bucchi, that got me thinking – in these weeks of pandemic isolations due the contagion from the unknown Coronavirus where East assured themselves a leading role : just like in our nocturnal dreams, the-totem-of-guard- is there, though completely asleep.
And describing it is possible – Massimo Bucchi confirms – but replacing it with a softer representation, otherwise our dream stops to be that wonderful world where we can take refuge to forget. Or from which we daily escape trivializing it upon waking, that is promoting it to an Ideal : because even the ‘soft’ representations can find us unprepared, but in the same time, and naively, arrogant.
In short : caring, or distracting oneself ? It is a crossroads for everyone, not avoidable.
How Massimo Bucchi came to conceive so precociously ‘West awoke late the East day’ we are not given to know, also because an artist usually stops looking for the reasons of his own thinking, in order to go on creating : and the creativity itself, which even requires talent and application, eludes verbalization that however never rejects a further, perhaps more fruitful, talking about.
Here we can observe having fun that an ancient compass is all that remains vital next to the monumental, sleeping stone lion, whose enormous paw released cannot cause fear, at least while he sleeps.
And this is how the finished work reaches the public, gratified with no work and no profit, whether it’s sculpture, music, or graphics : since satire is just one part of that universe – accessible to few – that remains humour, only human capacity to be able to sum up in very few words an innocent judgement which conscience doesn’t have time to gather, and it is immediately said.
‘Celui-qui-me-fait-guerRire’ is an aphorism of mine – no longer unconscious then - in recognizing Freud’ valuable insight about humour. So that, what is conscience then ?
That stable lump which discards laughter.
Marina Bilotta Membretti / Cernusco sul Naviglio - March 31, 2020
TutorSalus.net - Freudian journalism
I will resume April 13, Monday.
[1] It is the title for one of the sketches by Massimo Bucchi as published in the collection “Mappamondo”, 2016 / Publish.: “il Saggiatore”.
[2] Massimo Bucchi was born in Rome in 1941. He started as a reporter of crime news, and then dedicated himself to graphics as an ‘art director’. His passion for humour, cultivated since he was a boy will lead him to invest his talent in different and prestigious collaborations to which he is gradually called, and also in the film industry : his contributions of many years for “la Repubblica” certainly stand out, in addition to many awards received. He also cared interesting exhibitions of his own works.
Edvar Munch: the surprising lucidity of a surgeon.

Original painting by Stefano Frassetto (6).
“Why is it so horrifying the idea that removing is an experience of lying ?” (1)“
Maybe is still correct the above quotation by Giacomo B. Contri about a common experience, the anguish : about which we come to know very soon, already in early childhood, and towards which an initial, but disadvantageous defense is the removal of the experience given rise by anguish.
The exceptional talent of Edvar Munch in painting, and of only a few painters indeed (2), surely is in being able – that is infact the power of thinking – to go up again the origin of one’s anguish, untieing it up to weave a more profitable defense instead of the removal itself.
“I was walking along the road with two friends when the sun was setting, the sky suddenly coloured in blood red. I stopped, and really tired I leaned against a fence. On the black-blue fjord and on my own town there were blood and tongues of fire. My friends kept on trembling, and me too was still trembling with fear… And I was feeling that a big scream was pervading the nature…” (3)
In the shape of a visual hallucination which turns away the reality, Munch was describing in a note from his diary the experience of the ‘return of a removed memory’, the feared and hard-fought satisfaction, unsustainable indeed… The removal, as a matter of facts, still remains irresolute also if practiced, even it does menace a subject and his, or her own physical integrity too.
The 1893 painting belongs to the maturity of Munch who had already developed a competence not only in painting but also in his own relation with it. He sensed in painting, to which he applied himself by chance, a privileged and very personal way, but definitely alternative, to anguish. At school he had realized he could excel in psysics, chemistry and mathematics and chose to specialize at the ‘Drawing School‘ of Oslo, and then at the ‘School of Arts and Crafts‘ of Christiania in 1881 : but it was maybe only when Munch met Hans Jaeger (4), a not excellent writer and even psychologically disturbed in comparison with the reserved and discreet Edvar, that the writer did kick-start again a favourable, personal intuition into Munch’ thinking.
That was infact a real change of course for the painter and not at all ephemeral towards a sincerity he hadn’t known before, which approached him to the very reason of his past submissions, and also pointed out easily and precisely the point where he could correct his mistakes, and his ingenuity too that now became corrigible then : into Munch’ work, into his many repetitions of the same few pictures - not just ‘The scream‘, as a matter of facts - is therefore evident that his own deep interest was not the approval by the public.
There isn’t any pedagogical aim infact in his works, any attempt ‘to explain’ to the spectator, who could imagine everything when being in front of one of his pictures. Munch’ evident goal is to get to touch the tangle he himself was living in order to untie it, without any uncertainty and without any doubt.
Anguish flows into horror when it is not processed, Munch had seen such epilogues among his own relatives too, and had realized that it couldn’t be due to a motionless fate.
With the surprising lucidity of a surgeon, he could be building a very personal and favourable path of work, not to be reproduced but for its peculiar practicability.
Marina Bilotta Membretti / Cernusco sul Naviglio – October 26, 2019
TutorSalus.net - Freudian journalism
(1) ‘Lavoro dell’inconscio e lavoro psicoanalitico‘, by Giacomo B. Contri, 1985 SIC Edizioni.
(2) I’m going to dedicate an editorial to Renè Magritte, Belgian painter lived between 1898 and 1967 and considered one of the best interpreter of Surrealism.
(3) This is a memory, which Edvar Munch (Loten, Norway 1863 – Oslo 1944) managed to bring back on the frame of one of the four versions of ‘The scream’, the one of 1895. “The scream” (1893) is a work exhibited at the ‘National Gallery’ of Oslo.
(5) Hans Jaeger (1854-1910), wrote “Between Kristiania and Bohemen“ (1885) and became famous due to his raw controversies against the Norwegian culture rather than to his real value as an author and writer.
(6) Stefano Frassetto is born in Turin in 1968. After his degree in Architecture at ‘Politecnico’ he begun as graphic novelist for local magazines. In the ‘90s he edited in France too, on ‘Le Réverbère’ and on ‘Libération’ : then he created ‘Ippo’ for ‘Il Giornalino’ and then the stripe ‘35MQ’ for the swiss magazine ‘20 Minuti’. In 2000 he came into ‘La Stampa’ as portraitist for cultural page and the insert ‘Tuttolibri’, then for the weekly ‘Origami’. Today he works also for the swiss magazine ‘Le Temps’.
Freud tells about psychoanalysis in economical terms.

”Psychoanalysis… is certainly not the whole psychology, however that is its essential structure, maybe even its fundamental… Then any analyst must have learned, first of all, that psychology, or depth psychology, or even better the psychology of the unconscious.”[2]
To benefit from one’s calling/1.
“…After fortyone years of activity, the knowledge I got of myself tells me that I have never actually been a doctor. I’ve become a doctor having been forced to turn away from my original purposes, and the success in my life is in finding again indeed, after a tortuous very long deviation, the guidance of my own beginning…”[3]
We see that Freud was getting late to his own calling, in his maturity : and he realized it was already a profession, but original and new, that is never started before.
“…The aim for us analysts is making an analysis as complete and in-depth as possible together with our patient, whom we don’t like to bring relief welcoming him, or her, into a community, be it Catholic or Protestant or Socialist; instead what we like to do is enriching him, or her and get that richness from his or her own unconscious just making flow to his, or her ‘I’, both the hidden and therefore unapproachable energies due to the removal, and any further energy the ‘I’ is forced to waste without any fruit…”[4]
Freud effectively tells about psychoanalysis in economical terms : en enrichment which the removal makes unapproachable to the patient who, on the opposite, dissipates many energies just to keep an ineffective defense from the removal. Less than fifty years later, Jacques Lacan welcomes Freud.
“…And, about richness, why not starting indeed from the rich ? The rich owns a property. He buys, he buys eveything, eh! We can say that he buys a lot. However… the rich doesn’t pay…
First of all, we know very well that the surplus he everytime adds to himself, or herself… But, mainly, there is something he, or she, never pays for – the knowledge… The rich is no more a master, if not because he redeemed himself, or herself…
Since he is enriching himself, why he can buy everything without paying for it ? Because he, or she has nothing to do with enjoyment… Such knowledge the rich can buy as a surplus. But he just doesn’t pay for it…”[5]
Then the knowledge from psychoanalysis is a surplus, a benefit and a profit then, not just an enjoyment : Freud named ‘the benefit’ in his special work “Beyond the principle of pleasure”[6] as something profitable, quite different from the removal.
“The theory of removal is then the pillar on which the building of psychoanalysis does stands. It is the most essential element of psychoanalysis and it is nothing but the theoretic expression of a repeatable experience at will, if you proceed the analytical work with a neurotic patient without any hypnosis… It happens there to feel his, or her own resistance opposing to the analytical work and giving as a pretext the failure of memory, unfortunately with the aim of making it unuseful.
Hypnosis is hiding any resistance; so that we can say that psychoanalysis begins only with the technical innovation of giving up of hypnosis.”[7]
After attending, since 1886, the university lessons of Jean Martin Charcot in which, as in any future ‘direct’ therapy the work of the patient is not essential and his or her own guidance in the care too, Freud did favour the analytical work as it could be conducted by the patient only using his, or her own memory in the presence of the analyst.
“…The theoretic judgement if the resistance agrees with an amnesia, is leading inevitably us to conceive an unconscious psychic activity which is owned by psychoanalysis itself, and anyhow it is quite different from any philosophic speculations of unconscious.”[8]
Here it is why the conflict of interest between doctor and patient, not charging with the analytical work, can be on the other hand an obstacle in any said ‘direct’ therapy.
Marina Bilotta Membretti/ Cernusco sul Naviglio - October 1, 2019
TutorSalus.net - Freudian journalism
[1] ‘Il progresso in psicoanalisi’, Morris N. Eagle in ‘Psicoterapia e scienze umane’, Franco Angeli editore – Anno 2018, Vol.52, n.3
[2] S. Freud, , “Il problema dell’analisi condotta da non medici. Conversazione con un interlocutore imparziale”, 1925 : you can wonder how rarely they draw from that specific work by Freud.
[3] S. Freud, ibidem
[4] S. Freud, ibidem
[5] J.Lacan, “Il seminario – Libro XVII, Il rovescio della psicoanalisi 1969-1970” with an afterword by Jacques-Alain Miller – Giulio Einaudi editore SpA 2001 / “Le seminaire de Jacques Lacan, Livre XVII. L’envers de la psychanalyse” 1991 Edition du Seuil, Paris
[6] S.Freud, “Aldilà del principio di piacere” 1920, Bollati Boringhieri Vol.9 p.242 : “…that the benefit from the amphimixes has been then picked up and used in the following evolution”.
[7] S. Freud, , “The item of the analysis conducted by not doctors. Conversation with a fair interlocutor”, 1925.
[8] S.Freud, “For a history of the Psychoanalytical Movement”, 1914.
Outism[1], or...?

The above screenshot has been taken from ‘The kiss’, P. Picasso[2] (1969), at ‘Metamorfosi’ exposition - Palazzo Reale, Milan (October 18, 2018 – February 17, 2019)
'The Kiss' welcomes the visitor with a calculated vehemence, a programmed effect-driven aggression where the glassiness of the whites of the eyes and the animalistic quality of the wide-open eyes must prevail, along with the almost palpable relief of the sharp outlines, the agitated and uncontrollable gesture, the jarring colors: a hypnotic effect that has enchanted, until today, half a century of admirers all over the world.
In 1969[3], therefore, the passion for Picasso was already a matter of achievement and supremacy, a bullfight between two bulls and no humans, the hallucinated vision of a traumatized child who screams and keeps his distance. It is indeed a painting that does not let you get close, and anyone who does, retreats almost immediately, apologizing: "This painting is easier to understand from afar..."
Picasso was already 88 years old here, having been born in Malaga, Spain, in 1881: he would die in Mougins, France, a few years later, on April 8, 1973. How much time and how much thinking separate this painting from 'Maternity' of 1905?
There he was a moved but not enchanted author, a participant even if not the protagonist, portraying his wife with simplicity while she breastfeeds their firstborn: she is not divine, nor deified, nor is the child deified. She is a woman posing, yes, but without emphasis, a small ring on her ring finger and a red flower in her dark hair, the colours calm and everyday.
Was it the terror of normality? Very brief was that three-year period 1905-1907 that Picasso dubbed the 'Rose Period', in which the man pushed away the genius that the public instead demanded. "When a man watches a woman sleep, he tries to understand..." A period, the one between 1905 and 1907, the shortest of his very long body of work, that soon veered towards the Cubism promoted by Georges Braque, which Picasso would use to push his impatience for life to the absolute limit. 'Maternity' does not appear in this exhibition, although it is titled 'Metamorphoses', which indeed followed one after the other in the production of a man drunk on success, and desperate at thinking to move away from it.
Between 'Maternity' and 'The Kiss' there is 'Minotauromachy' of 1935, which is instead present at the exhibition at Palazzo Reale: it is an etching on copper with little white and much black, crowded with figures and breathless, so much so that one can almost feel its hoarse breath and the slipping away of life, and the little girl holding out a bouquet of flowers is not enough hope. Why so much darkness?
Picasso was already enjoying the abundant fruits of a global success. "When I love a woman, everything weeps, especially my soul..." Capable of an actual revolution that allowed him—thanks also to the choice of a new language—to de-structure reality, Picasso nevertheless managed to propose a 'personal' integral reconstruction of it that defied traditions and exposed the human as a 'normal', agonizing, and vital contradiction, not fearing to let himself be read by the public that acclaimed him with his exaggerations, his excesses, his inhibitions, his many abandonments.
Increasingly involved in the vortex that he would never have imagined when emigrating at a very young age from his provincial La Coruña in Spain, to arrive in Paris. "One must pass through what people see, reality. Tear it apart. Demolish structures..."
"... Women remain in the opposition, in antithesis, and even in Picasso's maturity, when he is by now an established artist, it is strange but there is no woman-ally... The woman remains looked at askance, with suspicion, the woman in freefall... Perhaps it was a defense of his, but at what sacrifice, with what renunciation?"[4]
Picasso's women begin with Maria Picasso y López, the Genoese mother whose surname, Picasso, he decided to take. "Like every artist, I am first and foremost a painter of woman... but for me, woman is essentially a machine for suffering..."
And then the child sister, at whose bedside he himself, as a child, makes a vow that leaves him terrified when she dies, and fate descends upon him like an inexorable, inextricable web: he will be a minotaur forever.
"It's strange..." - confesses Picasso in one of the transcribed phrases that can be read along the path of the Milan Exhibition. "In Paris I never draw fauns, centaurs, or mythological heroes... It is as if they lived only here in Spain...!" Picasso arrived in Paris in his early twenties with very little money and the heavy responsibility of the dreams of his family of origin, and of that Spanish province he left behind where everyone expected something from him, and something great, truly great.
"If all the stages of my life could be represented as points on a map and joined with a line, the result would be the figure of the Minotaur..."
His moving justification for the amorous passion that constantly sustained him and in which he equally took refuge dates back to the Cycladic culture[5]. "I take a vase and make a woman out of it. Using the old metaphor, I exploit it in the opposite direction and give her a new reason for living." The man recognizes himself as the savior of the woman, but with an effort that can suddenly transform him into a monster, thereby justifying his anger.
"The worst enemy of a painter is style." An improbable and winged knight of an utopian Justice in 'La guerre et la paix' of 1952, Picasso instead immersed himself with punitive taste into that mask of the monster that kept him caged. "In the bullfight I identify with the bull..."
And our thinking goes immediately to the unknown 'toreador' of his life, from whom until the very end he tried to save himself: a man, or a woman disguised as a man? But gradually, with growing indifference and an almost heroic self-complacency, the mask of the Minotaur replaced the man whom an immobile and eternal Destiny had caught up with, to attempt to wash away his faults.
The Cycladic women, slow and enormous, are the imaginary companions of the Minotaur; they too serve Destiny, an anchor to cling to in the face of the unexpected and painful abandonments of a hated and transgressed old age. "There is no past or future in art" – Picasso used to say. "If a work of art cannot live in the present, it must not be taken into account at all."
Marina Bilotta Membretti/ Cernusco sul Naviglio – May 2, 2019
TutorSalus.net – Freudian journalism
[1] 'Outing' indicates the public confession of a personal fact or experience, but nowadays it refers specifically to declaring an unresolved homosexuality, with the risk, therefore, of turning into an '-ism', and at times carrying an aggressive connotation.
[2] 'Metamorphosis', the Pablo Picasso exhibition curated by Pascale Picard, director of the Civic Museums of Avignon, was held at the Palazzo Reale in Milan from October 18, 2018, to February 17, 2019. It was part of the three-year European initiative 'Picasso – Méditerranée', promoted by the 'Musée Picasso' in Paris, which also loaned almost all of the works displayed in Milan.
[3] ‘The kiss’ by Picasso dates back to 1969.
[4] The question arose during the visit to the exhibition: Federica Membretti holds a degree in Economics and works as a Data Scientist.
[5] 6th–5th century b.C. / 'Seated Woman' (1920), created after the peak of Cubism and portrying Picasso's future wife, Olga Khokhlova, is also compared to this style of painting.